Methodology

How we rate books

Every book on EvidenceShelf gets an Evidence Score from 0 to 10. The score answers one question: do the ideas this book asks you to act on hold up against published research?

How we grade a book

  1. List the central claims. We pick the four to six ideas the book relies on most: the ones a reader would actually act on. We state each claim in plain words, as the book presents it.
  2. Check the research. For each claim we look for the strongest evidence first: meta-analyses, systematic reviews and large, preregistered replications. Single studies come after. Every source is checked by hand: it must exist, and it must say what we say it says.
  3. Mark each claim. A claim holds up when strong, replicated evidence supports it. It is mixed when the evidence is real but smaller, narrower or more contested than the book suggests. It has no support when no study tests it, or when the key studies failed to replicate.
  4. Grade the book. The score weighs how central each claim is to the book, not just how many claims pass. A book whose core idea holds up can score well even if a side chapter does not.
  5. Show our sources. Every review links to the studies behind each mark, so you can check our work.

What the score means

Score Evidence What it means
9–10 Strong Consensus findings, replicated many times.
7–8.5 Strong Solid research, with a few dated or debated passages.
5–6.5 Mixed The core idea is reasonable but overstated, cherry-picked or untested as a method.
3–4.5 Weak Little evidence, or relies on findings that did not replicate.
1–2.5 Weak Mostly opinion and anecdote.
0 None Pseudoscience, or advice that could cause harm.

A low score does not mean a book is useless. Many readers find a well-told story motivating. It means the book’s claims about why its advice works are not supported by research, so you should not expect the results it promises.

What we do not do

Updates and corrections

Research moves. When a new meta-analysis or a failed replication changes the picture, we update the review, change the date at the top, and adjust the score if needed. Found an error? Write to contact@evidenceshelf.com and we will check it.